Greetings & Welcome

I'm RevMo Crystal Hardin. Wife. Mother. Recovering Attorney. Photographer. Episcopal Priest. Writer. Preacher.

I often don’t know what I believe until I’ve written or preached it, and the preaching craft is one of my greatest joys. In an effort to refine that craft, I post sermons and musings here for public consumption.

CV, here
Publications, here

Learning to Stay | A Sermon on Grace, Vulnerability, and the Gift of Belonging

Learning to Stay | A Sermon on Grace, Vulnerability, and the Gift of Belonging

A Sermon by the Reverend Mother Crystal J. Hardin on the Twenty-Fourth Sunday after Pentecost, November 8, 2026.

Joshua 24:1-3a, 14-25; 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18; Matthew 25:1-13


It matters what stories we tell about God.

I grew up in the Bible Belt, which meant that I learned two things very early in life: Jesus loved me, and Jesus might come back at any moment.

The first was wonderful news.
The second was a little more complicated.

Because I understood that Jesus might come back at any moment, and that when he did, those who belonged to him would be taken up into heaven. And those who didn’t?

Well, they’d be left behind.

The sure and certain knowledge of this theology even showed up on the bumpers of those most confident in their salvation: In case of Rapture, car will be unmanned.

But this idea of Jesus’ return did not instill in me that same kind of confidence; instead, it was a terrifying prospect, especially when you’re a child who isn’t entirely sure she’s gotten this whole salvation thing right.

There were times I would call a friend and no one would pick up. I’d call someone else and they wouldn’t pick up either. And I’d begin to worry - a deep gut worry - that the Rapture had happened and I’d been left behind.

It’s funny. And it’s not.

Because I grew up loving God, wanting desperately to belong to God, and believing that belonging depended upon something I needed to do correctly.

And the problem with that sort of belonging is that you can never be quite sure you’ve done enough. At least, I never was.

The church told me God loved me. And I believed it.

But I also heard that God might leave me behind. Despite loving me. And that it could happen unexpectedly and without warning if my faith was measured and found wanting.

Both stories live inside me.

Every Christian community tells stories about God, intentionally and unintentionally. Sometimes these stories are spoken. And sometimes the stories we hear aren’t quite the stories someone meant to tell.

The stories we tell about God matter.

They shape how we understand ourselves, how we understand one another, and even how we understand what it means to be faithful.

Perhaps this is why Joshua, before asking the people of Israel to make a choice about their future, begins to first tell the story of their past.

Nearing the end of his life, Joshua gathers the tribes of Israel to renew their covenant with God. But before issuing any commands, he recounts God’s activity, some of which is missing from our reading this morning. Occasionally the lectionary people do that sort of thing.

The fuller narrative recounts God’s saving acts: calling Abraham, delivering Israel from Egypt, guiding the people through the wildness and bringing them into the promised land.

Only then does Joshua call for the people’s response: Choose this day whom you will serve (Joshua 24:15).

We are not meant to hear the imperative without the history.
The demand without the gift. The obligation without the grace.

Before Joshua asks the people to remember their promises to God, he asks them to remember God’s promises to them.

This does not lessen the call to faithfulness. Joshua demands a genuine choice, one that must become visible in the way the people live. And it’s not nothing that Joshua has gathered the tribes of Israel. Their promises are made together. They are choosing not simply how each of them will live, but what kind of people they will be.

Because, it’s one thing to tell a story about serving God; it’s another thing entirely to live that story.

And, the story Joshua tells is not about a people who got everything right. It’s about a God who remained faithful to a people who so often got things wrong.

If we begin with the story of God’s faithfulness, how might we hear some of the more difficult passages of Scripture differently?

In today’s Gospel, we hear the parable of the bridesmaids.

Ten bridesmaids await a bridegroom. Five are wise. Five are foolish. The bridegroom is delayed, and all ten fall asleep. When the announcement of his arrival finally comes, the foolish bridesmaids discover that their lamps are running out of oil. They ask the others to share, but the others refuse, saying there might not be enough. Instead, they suggest the foolish bridesmaids go and buy more.

And they do. They leave.

While they’re gone, the bridegroom arrives, the celebration begins, and the door is shut. When they return, they find themselves excluded. On the wrong side of the door, just like that.

I’ll be honest, this set of lectionary readings, and particular this parable, were once frightening to me. Read alongside passages like today’s reading from Thessalonians, it reinforced everything I feared about being left behind.

I don’t think I’m alone here; the quick assumption is that the moral of this story is to make sure we’re among the wise. Prepared. Plentiful oil. Right place, right time.

But it matters what stories we tell about God.

Consider the details that complicate such a straightforward reading.

For one thing, all ten bridesmaids fall asleep. The wise are no more vigilant than the foolish. And what does the oil represent? Faith? Good works? Readiness? Jesus never says.

And honestly, ya’ll, where are they buying oil this late at night.

But there’s something else about this story that has been bothering me. The five foolish bridesmaids were already there. Invited. Welcomed. Waiting.

When their lamps began running dry, they turned to the others and admitted their need. They asked for help. There’s a vulnerability in that request that would be easy to overlook. And the response they received was to go elsewhere.

So they left the very place where they were waiting for the bridegroom.

Now, I’m not suggesting that Jesus is telling us preparation doesn’t matter. Clearly it does. But I wonder whether we’ve become so preoccupied with having enough that we’ve forgotten who we were waiting for in the first place.

Our hope us not an adequate supply of oil; our hope is in Christ.

So, what if the foolish bridesmaids had stayed?

What if they had trusted that the invitation still stood? That the bridegroom wanted their presence more than their preparation?

What if the other bridesmaids had invited them to stay?

The parable doesn’t tell us what would have happened if the foolish bridesmaids had stayed. But I wonder what it says about us that we assume they had to leave.

And I wonder something else.

What kind of community allows us to admit that we do not have enough, and to stay anyway?

It matters what stories we tell about God.

And I wonder whether the answer to that question begins with the story we tell at the baptismal font.

We thank you, Almighty God, for the gift of water.

So begins the Thanksgiving Over the Water in our baptismal liturgy.

Over it the Holy Spirit moved in the beginning of creation. Through it you led the children of Israel out of their bondage in Egypt into the land of promise (BCP 306). 

Sound familiar?

Just as Joshua in our reading gathers the people to remember God's saving acts, the Church gathers at the font and tells that story again. But we aren’t simply remembering what God did long ago.

Through the waters of baptism, we are drawn into that story ourselves, joined to the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. And through Christ, to one another.

We receive you into the household of God (BCP 308). 

Because the story we tell at the font is not simply that God loves us. It is that God's love makes us a people.

A people whose lives are bound together. A people who are called not only to give, but also to receive. Not only to serve, but to be served. Not only to love, but to allow ourselves to be loved.

And there is a vulnerability in that.

We talk a great deal about what it means to give, particularly in the Church. Our time, our talents, our treasure. And rightly so. These gifts sustain our common life.

But receiving requires something different.

It asks us to admit that we are not self-sufficient. That sometimes we are the ones who need the meal, the phone call, the ride. Sometimes we are the ones whose lamps are running dry.

And I suspect that for many of us, admitting that is considerably more difficult than offering to help.

Because being needed feels good.
Needing someone else can be terrifying.

But what happens when we begin to trust that our place in this community does not depend upon what we can contribute?

What happens when we allow ourselves to be known as we actually are—not simply as the capable, generous, faithful people we would prefer to be?

Perhaps that is where the story we tell about God begins to become the story we live with one another.

I think about that little girl in Alabama, desperately calling the people she loved, terrified that they had all gone somewhere without her.

What I feared was not simply that I had failed some great test of faithfulness. What I feared was that I would be left alone.

And I wish I could tell that little Alabama girl what I know now: Your belonging is held in the faithfulness of Christ, not the adequacy of your own faith. And that, in baptism, God gives us something extraordinary: a place within a people called to love one another.

Not perfectly, of course.

We will fail one another. We will disappoint one another. Sometimes we will be the ones with empty lamps, and sometimes we will be the ones who don’t know how to help.

But we are learning to stay.

To stay with one another in grief and joy, in uncertainty and hope, in all the ordinary and extraordinary circumstances of our common life.

And I have seen this happen among us. I’ve seen the ways you accompany one another through illness and grief. The ways you celebrate together, bear one another’s burdens, and continue to show up for each other. Not always perfectly. But faithfully. And perhaps that is one of the greatest gifts of this community: people who tell us the story of God’s faithfulness when we’ve forgotten how to tell it to ourselves.

We are reflecting this season on what it means to live From the Font, For the World.

And perhaps this is where that life begins: in the relationships formed and sustained right here among us.

In the courage to let ourselves be known. In the willingness to accompany one another through suffering. In the joy of celebrating together. In the gifts we offer to sustain this common life and the ministries through which we share it with the world.

Because we cannot offer the world a story of grace that we are unwilling to receive ourselves.

And the story we are telling here at Holy Cross is not meant to remain here.

We are meant to carry the story into the world, through our ministries, our generosity, our care for our neighbors, and the relationships we build beyond these walls.

That is what our annual pledge campaign is about. Our pledges help sustain this common life —these relationships, these ministries, this shared witness —through which God’s love is received, practiced, and carried into the world.

It matters what stories we tell about God.

And the story entrusted to us is one of a love that will not abandon us, a love that binds us to Christ and to one another forever, a love that death itself cannot undo.

May we tell that story well.
And may we live it together.

Amen.

Whose Image Do You Bear? | A Sermon on Baptism, Grace, and God

Whose Image Do You Bear? | A Sermon on Baptism, Grace, and God